<advertisement>

CJRColumbia Journalism Review

10 Ideas for Better Coverage - CJR, November/December 1999
November/December 1999 | Contents

politics
10 Ideas for Better Coverage

 

Eleanor Clift
Contributing editor, Newsweek
 
Annotate each candidate's speech. Tell the reader what's real and what's rhetoric, what came from a focus group and what came from the candidate's own experience. Identify code words. What promises will hold up? Which ones are made to be broken?
 
Matthew Cooper
Washington correspondent, Time
 
Get off the plane. You can't ignore the road show, but a good question to ask is, 'If I'm standing around with fifty reporters, do I really need to be here?' Almost always the answer is no.
 
E.J. Dionne
Columnist, Washington Post
 
Do investigative reporting of ideas. Take what politicians say and do in the public arena as seriously as we take what we presume to be hidden. Examine the underlying implications of their ideas and proposals, and how things they say at election time square with what they've done in the past.
 
Elizabeth Drew
Author
 
Make it clear polls are an ephemeral phenomenon, and very shaky as predictors. Excessive emphasis on polls actually un-informs the public. For example, it was clear early on that Bill Bradley could be an effective anti-Gore, but when he pulled virtually dead even with Gore in New Hampshire in early September, it was treated as a surprise.
 
James Fallows
Writer
 
Have the best reporters play historian. Imagine themselves as a famous historian of 2050, and answer this question: Based on what we know now, what is likely to be interesting or important about this election fifty years from now?
 
Gwen Ifill
Senior correspondent, NewsHour with Jim Lehrer
 
Resist the urge to make up a story to relieve boredom. Politics often unfolds in a fascinating and dramatic way, but sometimes it doesn't do that right away. In the meantime, we can't let Donald Trump and Warren Beatty tell us what the news is. Use news smarts. Don't be afraid to ask someone pursing a fantasy: "Are you joking?"
 
Peter Prichard
President, Freedom Forum
 
Give candidates a few minutes on each evening newscast to deliver an unedited message. They could be organized around issues or be free-form. In an era of fifteen-second sound bites, letting candidates talk a little longer would serve the public well.
 
Jay Rosen
Journalism professor
 
Redefine horse race to include the struggle beyond poll rankings and votes. The money race. The idea race. The interactivity race (who's ahead in the drive to make campaigning genuinely interactive?) The race to learn more about the country they want to lead. Give candidates grades on all these races. Publish charts and graphs that show what's happening.
 
Hedrick Smith
Author
 
Print detailed issue positions -- I'm talking an entire page -- on issues people have said are important. Do it every week of the campaign. This notion that issues covered once have been covered is nonsense.
 
Judy Woodruff
Senior anchor, CNN
 
TV news should provide thorough and repeated examinations of each candidate's record, public and private. Do not wait until we are down to two or three candidates to expend the resources.